Carter Crushes Comeback as O’Sullivan Falls in German Masters Shock
Ali Carter produced a gritty and composed performance to defeat Ronnie O’Sullivan 5–3 at the German Masters, booking his place in the last 16 after a contest that swung dramatically in momentum. What initially looked like a straightforward victory for Carter turned into a stern test of nerve, as O’Sullivan clawed his way back from a 3–0 deficit to level the match, only for Carter to dig deep and close it out in the final two frames.
Carter started the match sharply, capitalising on uncharacteristic errors from O’Sullivan and taking full advantage of early opportunities. His tactical discipline and solid break-building allowed him to establish a commanding 3–0 lead, putting the seven-time world champion firmly on the back foot. At that stage, it appeared Carter was cruising toward a rare win over his long-time rival.
However, writing off Ronnie O’Sullivan is rarely wise. The Rocket responded in trademark fashion, rediscovering his rhythm and raising his scoring to reel off three frames on the bounce. With the match suddenly tied at 3–3, the momentum had completely shifted, and many expected O’Sullivan to push on and complete the comeback.
Instead, Carter showed resilience and mental strength that has sometimes eluded him in big matches against O’Sullivan. Refusing to be rattled, he tightened up tactically, forced mistakes, and seized his chances when they came. Winning the final two frames, Carter sealed a 5–3 victory and progressed to the last 16 — just his second career win over O’Sullivan outside of the Championship League in 23 attempts.
The result sparked mixed reactions among fans and pundits alike. Some critics of O’Sullivan were quick to celebrate the defeat, while many supporters rushed to his defence, suggesting the Rocket was either below his best or simply not fully invested. There is also growing speculation that O’Sullivan is building toward one final push at the World Championship in April, where an eighth Crucible crown would complete an unprecedented “8-8-8” haul across the Worlds, UK Championship, and Masters — a fitting potential farewell to an extraordinary career.
Elsewhere at the German Masters, Tom Ford secured a solid 5–3 victory over Zhao Xintong, while Stuart Bingham impressed with a convincing 5–2 win against Scott Donaldson. Meanwhile, Mark Selby edged ahead 4–3 against Xu Si in a tense, closely fought encounter that remains finely balanced.
Carter’s victory stands out as one of the tournament’s defining moments so far — a reminder that on his day, he remains a formidable competitor capable of standing tall against snooker’s greatest name.
