Will Injury Woes Force the 49ers to Gamble on Losing Dre Greenlaw in Free Agency?

Dre Greenlaw’s return to the San Francisco 49ers in 2024 provided an immediate spark, showcasing the qualities the team had been missing during his absence. Although his time on the field was brief, Greenlaw’s impact was undeniable, both in his production and the energy he brought to the team. Despite his importance, the possibility of Greenlaw and the 49ers parting ways looms large as he approaches unrestricted free agency in March.

The 49ers face significant financial constraints, with upcoming extensions for quarterback Brock Purdy and tight end George Kittle taking priority. Yet, the organization has been vocal about their desire to retain Greenlaw. At the season’s end, head coach Kyle Shanahan emphasized their commitment: “We’re doing everything in the world we can to bring Greenlaw back… we’re not into losing really good players who are unbelievable people.”

However, fitting Greenlaw’s contract into an already tight salary cap is no easy task. Beyond the financial challenges, the 49ers must also grapple with concerns about Greenlaw’s durability. While his production and leadership on the field remain top-tier, his recent Achilles injury raises questions about his long-term availability. Greenlaw and his representatives will likely argue that his health will improve with more recovery time, but for a team that values consistency, the risk of recurring injuries is a significant factor.

Despite these concerns, the 49ers know Greenlaw’s value extends beyond the stat sheet. General manager John Lynch echoed Shanahan’s sentiments, expressing mutual interest between the team and Greenlaw to finalize a deal. However, if San Francisco doesn’t offer a competitive contract, another team may seize the opportunity to sign the talented linebacker.

Ultimately, the decision will come down to balancing risk and reward. If the 49ers are serious about keeping Greenlaw, they must back their words with action. Letting him walk could leave a void that’s difficult to fill, both on and off the field.