Miami Dolphins’ 2025 Draft: A Defining Moment for Grier and McDaniel

With nearly three months left until the NFL Draft, the Miami Dolphins have one clear objective—nail their selections. General manager Chris Grier and head coach Mike McDaniel face immense pressure to land immediate-impact players, not just developmental projects who walk after their rookie contracts. Given Miami’s roster gaps and limited free agency flexibility, this draft could define Grier’s tenure.

Miami’s 2024 draft class had some bright spots—edge rusher Chop Robinson showed promise, and sixth-round receiver Malik Washington contributed. However, second-round picks like Cam Smith and Patrick Paul barely saw the field, while trade-up acquisition Jaylen Wright and defensive lineman Mohamed Kamara were non-factors. That cannot happen again. The Dolphins need starters in 2025, and this mock draft focuses on filling key voids.

First Round (13th Overall) – Kelvin Banks Jr., T/G, Texas

Miami’s offensive line has been a persistent weakness, and it’s time to invest heavily in the trenches. Kelvin Banks Jr. brings versatility, capable of playing both tackle and guard. With Austin Jackson under contract at right tackle, Banks could start at guard before transitioning outside when needed. His physicality and technique make him a plug-and-play option and a long-term building block.

Second Round (48th Overall) – Xavier Watts, S, Notre Dame

With Jordan Poyer and Jevon Holland expected to depart in free agency, safety becomes a glaring need. Xavier Watts is a high-IQ, physical safety with an impressive 89.7 PFF grade in 2024. He’s coachable and still developing, making him a prime candidate to step in as a Day 1 starter. Miami may need additional reinforcements in free agency, but Watts provides a strong foundation.

Third Round (98th Overall) – Tate Ratledge, OG, Georgia

After losing Robert Hunt in free agency, the Dolphins need to rebuild the interior offensive line. Ratledge is a powerful guard who excels in both run and pass blocking. With Banks addressing one guard spot, Ratledge can compete for the other, offering Miami long-term stability up front.

Fourth Round (114th Overall) – Barrett Carter, LB, Clemson

Carter’s production dipped in 2024, but his raw athleticism and versatility make him a valuable addition. He has potential as both an off-ball linebacker and edge defender, though his coverage skills need refinement. He’ll require development but has the ceiling to become a starting-caliber player.

Fourth Round (134th Overall) – Dorian Strong, CB, Virginia Tech

Cornerback is an underrated need for Miami, with concerns about depth behind Jalen Ramsey and Kendall Fuller. Cam Smith’s slow development has left question marks, making depth additions crucial. Strong is a solid coverage corner with potential but needs refinement before stepping into a major role.

Conclusion

This draft prioritizes the Dolphins’ biggest weaknesses—offensive line, safety, linebacker, and cornerback—while ensuring that early-round picks contribute immediately. With a strong draft class, Miami can solidify its roster and set itself up for sustained success, making this a make-or-break year for Grier and McDaniel.