Pacers Fans Slam Rick Carlisle for Questionable Decision in Game 5 Loss
Indiana Pacers head coach Rick Carlisle faced intense backlash on Monday night following a highly scrutinized coaching decision in Game 5 of the NBA Finals. With the series tied 2-2 against the Oklahoma City Thunder, every possession mattered — but fans believe Carlisle made a costly misstep at a pivotal moment.
Early in the fourth quarter, Carlisle subbed out T.J. McConnell — who had provided energy and stability at point guard — in favor of an injured Tyrese Haliburton. Though Haliburton had started the game, his limited mobility due to a lingering hamstring issue had visibly affected his performance throughout the series.
Despite the change, Indiana stayed within striking distance, closing the Thunder’s lead to just two points at one stage. However, many Pacers fans took to social media to voice their frustration, arguing that the team’s comeback was achieved in spite of Haliburton’s presence, not because of it.
Critics questioned why Carlisle stuck with Haliburton for most of the final quarter, leaving McConnell — who had been effective on both ends — on the bench until the outcome was essentially sealed. By the time McConnell returned, Oklahoma City had pulled away, eventually sealing a 120-109 victory and taking a 3-2 lead in the series.
With the Finals now hanging in the balance, Carlisle’s decision has become a lightning rod for criticism. Whether it was loyalty to his All-Star or a misjudged tactical call, the move has left many fans second-guessing the leadership at the most crucial stage of the season.
