Parramatta in Crisis: Jason Ryles’ Bold Gamble Backfires as Eels Plunge to Rock Bottom

Parramatta’s nightmare start to the season has put rookie coach Jason Ryles’ bold decisions under the microscope, with the Eels sitting at 0-4 for the first time since 2018—the year they collected the wooden spoon. Ryles took over the club with a clear vision, making sweeping changes by parting ways with experienced players and promoting youth, but the results have been disastrous so far.

The most controversial moves included the departures of long-time captain Clint Gutherson, star forward Reagan Campbell-Gillard, and powerful winger Maika Sivo. Adding to the upheaval, Ryles relegated Bryce Cartwright, Ryan Matterson, and Kelma Tuilagi to NSW Cup while debuting untested youngsters from the bench. The Eels now find themselves at the bottom of the ladder with the worst attack and defence in the competition.

Fox League panelists weighed in on the situation, questioning Ryles’ approach. Michael Ennis compared his strategy to Brian Smith’s infamous “clean house” philosophy, where a new coach removes established leaders to mold a young squad in their vision. Meanwhile, James Hooper noted that legendary coach Wayne Bennett takes the opposite approach—assessing the roster first before making changes. He argued that Ryles’ aggressive overhaul might have backfired, particularly in the case of Gutherson.

Braith Anasta and Hooper highlighted Gutherson’s immense value, pointing to his leadership, defensive organisation, and relentless energy. His influence was on full display in the Melbourne Storm clash, where he was a key factor in St George Illawarra’s victory. The panel speculated that, with hindsight, Ryles might reconsider his decision to move on from Gutherson.

Parramatta’s rapid decline is stark, considering their 2022 grand final appearance. The club once believed they had a premiership-ready squad, leading to Brad Arthur’s sacking. Now, under Ryles, they are in crisis. While the rookie coach has a four-year deal, the pressure is mounting as fans and analysts question whether his drastic approach was the right call.