Matty Johns: The Harsh Realities Facing Brown’s Knights Move

The Newcastle Knights’ decision to sign Dylan Brown on a 10-year, $13 million deal has ignited debate within the NRL community. Club legend Matty Johns has voiced concerns about Brown’s ability to fill the halfback role—an ongoing issue for the Knights.

Johns argues that Brown has primarily excelled as a five-eighth, complementing a dominant playmaker who dictates the game’s tempo. Shifting him into the role of the chief organiser may not suit his natural style. “Dylan is a player who can influence a game significantly, but first, he needs someone to steer the contest,” Johns explained. “He’s not the organising halfback Newcastle desperately needs right now.”

Beyond positional concerns, the financial implications of the deal have also raised eyebrows. With Kalyn Ponga already occupying a large portion of the salary cap, committing such a hefty sum to Brown could limit the club’s ability to strengthen other crucial areas. Johns cautioned, “Spending $13 million over a decade on Dylan Brown isn’t smart business—especially when they’ve clearly paid overs.”

While Brown’s talent is undeniable, the fundamental question remains: Can he successfully transition into the playmaking general the Knights require? If he struggles to take on that leadership role, Newcastle may find themselves still searching for a true game-controlling halfback despite their massive investment. Ultimately, this signing represents a high-risk gamble—one that could either transform the Knights’ fortunes or leave them with an expensive piece that doesn’t quite fit the puzzle.