Clutch Champion vs. Consistent King: Who Truly Deserves NASCAR’s Driver of the Year in 2024
Selecting the 2024 NASCAR Cup Series Driver of the Year is no easy task, as each candidate brings a unique case to the table. Here’s a breakdown of the top contenders:
Joey Logano
**Pros:**
Joey Logano captured his third NASCAR Cup Series championship, cementing his place among legends like Richard Petty and Jeff Gordon, who achieved similar milestones before age 35. Logano’s four wins, including three during the playoffs (Las Vegas II, Atlanta II, Phoenix II), highlight his ability to perform under pressure. He also added an All-Star Race win at North Wilkesboro to his achievements.
**Cons:**
Despite the championship, Logano’s season was far from dominant. His 17.1 average finish ranked 13th in the series, and he only led 414 laps — the third fewest by a champion since 1972. His regular season performance, with just one win and a 15th-place standing before the playoff reset, underwhelmed. Moreover, 11 finishes of 25th or worse suggest inconsistency.
Kyle Larson
**Pros:**
Larson was a force throughout the season, leading the series in wins (6), laps led (1700), and stage wins (12). His victories spanned various track types, showcasing versatility, including a marquee win at Indianapolis. Larson also excelled in qualifying, securing five poles, and nearly claimed the regular-season championship despite missing the Coca-Cola 600 to compete in the Indianapolis 500.
**Cons:**
Larson’s major drawback was failing to advance to the Championship 4, despite his dominant stats. His inconsistency in stringing together strong finishes — no more than two consecutive top 10s — raised questions about his ability to sustain momentum in a grueling season.
Ultimately, the choice between Logano’s clutch playoff performance and Larson’s season-long dominance depends on what one values more: postseason success or consistent excellence. For many, Larson’s six wins and statistical superiority might outweigh Logano’s playoff heroics.
